In a city known for excellence, a few names continue to rise above the rest. Charlotte Plastic Surgery is proud to announce that four of our board-certified plastic surgeons—Dr. Ashley Chandler, Dr. J. Walter Dutton, Dr. Jack Scheuer, and Dr. Theo Nyame have been named to the 2025 Castle Connolly Top Doctors® list for Plastic Surgery.
This distinction isn’t handed out lightly. It’s not paid for, not advertised, and not based on popularity contests. Castle Connolly’s Top Doctor recognition is peer-nominated and rigorously vetted, highlighting the most trusted and respected physicians in the country. It’s a sign of both professional mastery and patient-centered care, and this year, it shines in the halls of Charlotte Plastic Surgery.
What Is the Castle Connolly Top Doctor List?
For over 30 years, Castle Connolly Medical Ltd. has curated its Top Doctors list based on nominations from physicians nationwide. It’s one of the most respected honors in medicine—not because it’s flashy, but because it’s trusted.
Each doctor is evaluated for:
- Educational background
- Board certification
- Hospital affiliations
- Professional achievements
- Dedication to patient outcomes
Only about 7% of the nation's licensed physicians make the final list. The fact that four of them practice under one roof? That’s not just impressive—it’s rare.
Meet Charlotte’s Castle Connolly Top Plastic Surgeons
Dr. Ashley Chandler
Specialty: Breast Surgery, Breast Implant Removal, Aesthetic Reconstruction
Dr.
Chandler brings a calm confidence to her work—meticulous in detail, patient in
consultation, and
precise in execution. With training under Dr. Dennis Hammond, one of the leading
minds in
aesthetic breast surgery, she’s known for creating results that feel elegant and
true to the
individual. Patients trust her not just because of her technical skill, but
because she listens
with purpose.
Learn more about Dr. Chandler →
Dr. J. Walter Dutton
Specialty: Facial Rejuvenation, Breast & Body Procedures
Dr.
Dutton trained at the Cleveland Clinic—one of the world’s most prestigious centers
for aesthetic
surgery. He brings that level of refinement into every case, from deep plane
facelifts to mommy
makeovers. His demeanor is quiet, his results speak volumes, and his patients often
describe him
as the person who helped them feel like themselves again, just refreshed.
Learn more about Dr. Dutton →
Dr. Jack Scheuer
Specialty: Rhinoplasty, Eyelid Surgery, Facial Aesthetics
A
blend of artistic vision and surgical rigor defines Dr. Scheuer’s approach. With
fellowship
training at Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital and a deep passion for
precision, he excels
in procedures that require nuance, especially rhinoplasty and facial refinement. His
“liquid
rhino” preview technique has become a modern bridge for patients considering a
surgical change
but needing clarity first.
Learn more about
Dr. Scheuer →
Dr. Theo Nyame
Specialty: Cosmetic Breast & Body Surgery
Graduating
from Harvard Medical School and training at Harvard’s combined plastic surgery
residency, Dr.
Nyame’s credentials are matched only by his warmth and vision. Originally from
Ghana, he brings
a global perspective to his surgical technique and believes deeply in the power of
aesthetic
surgery to change lives, not just looks. Known for his balance of strength and
empathy, his
patients describe him as both a brilliant surgeon and a true partner in care.
Learn more about
Dr. Nyame →
Why Peer Recognition Matters in Plastic Surgery
It’s one thing for a patient to leave a five-star review. It’s another when doctors, who understand the complexity of surgical procedures, the precision required, and the responsibility it carries, choose to nominate other doctors for their excellence. That level of recognition carries weight.
The Castle Connolly Top Doctor distinction isn’t about popularity or online ratings. It’s about reputation within the medical community itself—among peers who’ve seen what others haven’t. These are the people who’ve observed each other’s techniques in the OR, consulted on complicated cases, and witnessed outcomes not just at one-month post-op, but years down the line.
Peer recognition cuts through marketing claims. It’s informed. It’s earned. It reflects:
- Surgical consistency under pressure
- Sound clinical decision-making
- Skillful patient communication
- A pattern of excellent results—not just one-off wins
And in the world of plastic surgery, where outcomes are deeply personal and highly visible, that kind of trust is invaluable.
Peers nominate those they would refer their own patients to—or even their family members. That’s how you know this isn’t just another industry badge. It’s a signal of who other experts truly believe is doing right by their patients.
For patients in Charlotte and beyond, seeing that your surgeon is a Castle Connolly Top Doctor means you're in the care of someone whose expertise is acknowledged not just by reviews or reputation, but by those who know the craft inside and out.
One Team. Four Honorees. Countless Lives Changed.
At Charlotte Plastic Surgery, excellence isn’t a marketing slogan—it’s the expectation. Since 1951, we’ve built our practice around that idea: Do great work. Put patients first. Evolve constantly.
Each of our surgeons brings something unique to the table. And because of our collaborative model, we’re able to pair each patient with the provider whose experience and approach best align with their goals.
Whether you’re considering a facelift or breast augmentation or are simply exploring your options, this recognition underscores something we already know: You’re in exceptional hands.
Explore Your Options with Charlotte’s Best
Not sure where to start? You don’t need to be. Our patient coordinators are here to walk you through your options, schedule consultations with the right provider, and support you every step of the way.
When the time comes to make a change—big or small—make it with confidence.
📍 Two locations in Charlotte | ✆ (704) 228-4481
Request a consultation →
